hdtv kdl-32s5100
hdtv kdl-32s5100

The Sony Bravia KDL-52Z5100 vs the KDL-52XBR9

The Sony Bravia KDL-52Z5100 and the Sony Bravia KDL-52XBR9 are two of Sony's top models for 2009, which is why you might want to consider taking home one of them to be the new centerpiece of your living room. Both models seem identical, though, so which one is the better model?

To answer this question, let's start with comparing their designs. At first glance, the two may appear alike but take a closer look and you will find some small yet noticeable differences. To be specific, while both have stylish, thin frames, the frame of the KDL-52XBR9 is the same width on all sides, while the frame of the KDL-52Z5100 is slightly thicker at the bottom, where you will see a glimpse of its dual speakers. On the other hand, the (four) speakers of the KDL-52XBR9 are invisible, making it look more attractive.

There is also a difference in the lighting used by both models, although this is not discernible to most. While both use fluorescent lighting and not the LED lighting that many look for in LCD HDTVs, the KDL-52XBR9 uses WCG-CCFL as opposed to the plain CCFL used by the KDL-52Z5100, which means it has a slightly wider color gamut. The KDL-52XBR9 is equipped with the Sony's Live Color Creation technology, too, which produces deeper red and green shades and more accurate and vibrant colors overall, resulting in images that burst to life on your screen.

Apart from these and the fact that the KDL-52XBR9 has a dynamic contrast ratio of 1,000,000:1 compared to the 100,000:1 ratio of the KDL-52Z5100, the picture quality offered by the KDL-52Z5100 and the KDL-52XBR9 are basically the same. In fact, everything else is. They both produce excellent images, though not necessarily awesome, and are equipped with the Sony Motionflow 240Hz technology to prevent blurring during fast-action sequences.

Both also share the same interactive features, namely Yahoo widgets to keep you posted on the latest weather, news and stock market updates, built-in video streaming capability, which means you can watch your favorite online videos from Amazon on Demand or YouTube and other providers without having to buy the Bravia Internet Video Link, and enhanced DLNA compliance, allowing you to stream picture, music and video files stored on the other computers in your network.

Even in terms of energy consumption, both the Sony Bravia KDL-52Z5100 and the KDL-52XBR9 are at par, exceeding Energy Star 3.0 standards with an option to cut down energy consumption by limiting the peak brightness of the screen with just two steps, a room-lighting sensor to adjust screen brightness, a mode that lets you turn off the screen when listening to music and a mode that automatically turns of the TV when not in use.

The connectivity suite of each model is impressive, too, with three HDMI inputs on the side panel for easy access, along with the USB port and VGA input, and another one at the rear, with the component video connections and most of the audio connections for both analog and digital devices.

So which one should you get? If you want to have a more stylish HDTV with deeper blacks and slightly better picture quality, the KDL-52XBR9 is the obvious choice, but keep in mind that the Sony Bravia KDL-52Z5100 is just as good in most aspects and yet not as expensive.

About the Author


Edward is an electronics expert who writes Sony HD TV reviews. To learn more about HDTV's, visit HDTVReviewLab.com

Sony Bravia S-Series KDL-32S5100 32-Inch 1080p LCD HDTV, Black Sony Bravia S-Series KDL-32S5100 32-Inch 1080p LCD HDTV, Black
List Price: $699.99
Used From: $520.00

Sony’s S-series TVs put amazing picture quality and stunning dynamic contrast in reach for value-oriented consumers who want to step up into the Sony Full HD 1080p experience. These TVs represent the entry-level models in Sony’s large screen offerings in 2009 and offer the superior resolution and contrast, advanced image processing features, and variety of HD input options available on high-end BRAVIA HDTVs -- all in an affordable package...

Sony BRAVIA S-Series KDL-46S5100 46-Inch 1080p LCD HDTV, Black Sony BRAVIA S-Series KDL-46S5100 46-Inch 1080p LCD HDTV, Black
List Price: $1,199.99
Used From: $700.00

Sony’s S-series TVs put amazing picture quality and stunning dynamic contrast in reach for value-oriented consumers who want to step up into the Sony Full HD 1080p experience. These TVs represent the entry-level models in Sony’s large screen offerings in 2009 and offer the superior resolution and contrast, advanced image processing features, and variety of HD input options available on high-end BRAVIA HDTVs -- all in an affordable package...

Mount World 1212 Universal Tilt and Swivel Articulating Arm Corner Wall Mount (25 Mount World 1212 Universal Tilt and Swivel Articulating Arm Corner Wall Mount (25" Extension) for Sony HDTV BRAVIA KLV-40ZX1M KDL-32L5000 KDL-37L5000 KDL-40S5100 KDL-46S5100 KDL-46V5100 KDL-46VE5 KDL-40W5100 KDL-40XBR7 KDL-46XBR8 KDL-32XBR9 KDL-40XBR9 KDL-46XBR9 KDL-40Z5100 KDL-46Z5100,KDL-46NX800,KDL-46NX700,KDL-46EX700,KDL-46EX600, KDL-46EX500,KDL-46EX400,KDL-40NX700,KDL-40EX700, KDL-40EX600,KDL-40EX500,KDL-40EX40B,KDL-40EX400
Sale Price: $54.99

UNIVERSAL 32-52" LED/LCD SINGLE ARM TV/DISPLAY MOUNT. This mount features 28lbs of heavy gauge cold-rolled steel for a stable and secure mount. The mount collapses to less than 4", extends out to 25", tilts forward/downward 0-15 degrees and swivels 180 degrees

Ultra Slim Flat TV LCD HDTV LED Plasma WALL MOUNT Bracket (32 - 42 inch screen) up to 120lb BLACK (VESA up to 400x400) Ultra Slim Flat TV LCD HDTV LED Plasma WALL MOUNT Bracket (32 - 42 inch screen) up to 120lb BLACK (VESA up to 400x400)
Sale Price: $17.99

Ultra Slim Low Profile Wall Mount for LCD, LED & Plasma TV's (32"~42" / max 120lbs) - Black This is a unique and simple mounting solution for all Slim LED/LCD HDTVs. If you're looking for the slimmest mount available for your TV or monitor, this is the right mount for you! The mounting arms sit at an ultra slim distance of 8mm from the wall making for a very discrete installation...

Ultra-Slim Black Adjustable Tilt/Tilting Wall Mount Bracket for Sony KDL-32S5100 (KDL32S5100) 32 Ultra-Slim Black Adjustable Tilt/Tilting Wall Mount Bracket for Sony KDL-32S5100 (KDL32S5100) 32" inch LCD HDTV TV/Television - Low Profile
Sale Price: $34.99

This is an Ultra-Slim Angle Adjustable Black Wall Mount Bracket for LCD and Plasma Televisions. Using this mount, the back of your television is only 1.81" from the wall when the mounting arms are parallel to the wall...

Brand new AVF Mounts Tilt Swivel and Extend Adjustable Multi-Position TV Wallmount for LCD LED Plasma TV HDTV (VESA up to 700x400, 40 - 65 inch Screen) Brand new AVF Mounts Tilt Swivel and Extend Adjustable Multi-Position TV Wallmount for LCD LED Plasma TV HDTV (VESA up to 700x400, 40 - 65 inch Screen)
List Price: $199.99
Sale Price: $159.99

The AVF Super Slim ZL8655-A is a multi-position TV wall mount for 40" - 65" flat panel HDTVs, including LCDs and LED TVs. Fingertip adjustment makes positioning simple with easy motion through the entire range of movement...

Sony BRAVIA V-Series KDL-46V5100 46-Inch 1080p 120Hz LCD HDTV, Black Sony BRAVIA V-Series KDL-46V5100 46-Inch 1080p 120Hz LCD HDTV, Black
List Price: $1,599.99
Used From: $759.99

For consumers who want an HDTV that keeps pace with fast-action movies, sports, and game play, Sony BRAVIA V-Series Flat Panel HDTVs combine Full HD 1080p performance and Motionflow 120Hz technology for an amazing viewing experience...

VideoSecu Plasma Flat Panel Screen HDTV LCD TV Wall Mount Bracket for Most SONY KDL-32XBR6 KDL-32N4000 KDL-32M4000 KDL-32M4000/R KDL-32M4000/T KDL-32M4000/W KDL-32L4000 KDL-32S3000 KDL-32M300032 KDL-32EX400 KDL-32BX300 KDL-32L5000 KDL-32EX600 KDL-32EX500 KDL-32EX40B KDL-32EX308 FWD-32LX2F KDL-37XBR6 KDL-37N4000 KDL-37M4000 KDL-37L400 KDL-40NX700 KDL-40EX700 KDL-40EX600 KDL-40EX500 KDL-40EX40B KDL-40EX400 KDL-40XBR7 KDL-40XBR6 KDL-40XBR5 KDL-40W4100 KDL-40Z4100/B KDL-40V4100 KDL-40V4150 KDL-40S4100 KDL-40W3000 KDL-40s3000 KDL-40XBR2 KDL-40XBR3 KDL-42V4100 KDL46EX500 KDL46EX700 KDL46EX400 KDL-46S4100 KDL-46XBR8 KDL-46XBR6 KDL-46W4100 KDL-46Z4100/B KDL-46Z4100/S KDL-46W300 KDL-46V4100 KDL-46S4100 KDL-46S3000 KDL-46Z4100/B KDL-46W5100 KDL-46NX800 KDL-46NX700 KDL-46EX700 KDL-46EX600 KDL-46EX500 KDL-46EX400 KDL-46V5100 KDL-52XBR6 KDL-52XBR7 KDL-52W4100 KDL-52V4100 KDL-52W300 KDL-52NX800 KDL-52EX700 KDL-55EX500 KDL60EX700 KDL-60EX500 B35 VideoSecu Plasma Flat Panel Screen HDTV LCD TV Wall Mount Bracket for Most SONY KDL-32XBR6 KDL-32N4000 KDL-32M4000 KDL-32M4000/R KDL-32M4000/T KDL-32M4000/W KDL-32L4000 KDL-32S3000 KDL-32M300032 KDL-32EX400 KDL-32BX300 KDL-32L5000 KDL-32EX600 KDL-32EX500 KDL-32EX40B KDL-32EX308 FWD-32LX2F KDL-37XBR6 KDL-37N4000 KDL-37M4000 KDL-37L400 KDL-40NX700 KDL-40EX700 KDL-40EX600 KDL-40EX500 KDL-40EX40B KDL-40EX400 KDL-40XBR7 KDL-40XBR6 KDL-40XBR5 KDL-40W4100 KDL-40Z4100/B KDL-40V4100 KDL-40V4150 KDL-40S4100 KDL-40W3000 KDL-40s3000 KDL-40XBR2 KDL-40XBR3 KDL-42V4100 KDL46EX500 KDL46EX700 KDL46EX400 KDL-46S4100 KDL-46XBR8 KDL-46XBR6 KDL-46W4100 KDL-46Z4100/B KDL-46Z4100/S KDL-46W300 KDL-46V4100 KDL-46S4100 KDL-46S3000 KDL-46Z4100/B KDL-46W5100 KDL-46NX800 KDL-46NX700 KDL-46EX700 KDL-46EX600 KDL-46EX500 KDL-46EX400 KDL-46V5100 KDL-52XBR6 KDL-52XBR7 KDL-52W4100 KDL-52V4100 KDL-52W300 KDL-52NX800 KDL-52EX700 KDL-55EX500 KDL60EX700 KDL-60EX500 B35
Sale Price: $24.99

This is Angle Adjustable Wall Bracket for LCD Plasma. This Flat Wall Mount supports most 30" to 60" flat panel screen and plasma TVs up to 135 lb weight, please do check TV VESA and weight before placing order...

Mount-It! Ultra Thin Wall Mount Bracket fits 23-37 inch LCD LED TV HDTV Plasma (up to 165lb/75kg - VESA 400x200) Mount-It! Ultra Thin Wall Mount Bracket fits 23-37 inch LCD LED TV HDTV Plasma (up to 165lb/75kg - VESA 400x200)
Sale Price: $19.99

Ultra Thin Wall Mount For HDTV 23-37" Features: Super Low Profile Fixed Wall Bracket Scratch resistant and durable steel construction in black finish Integrated bubble level to ensure precise level mount Fits most: 23" to 37" flat panels, LED HDTV screens Supports up to 165 lbs / 75 kgs...

Mount World 1262 Black Swivel Tilt Wall Mount for Sony HDTV BRAVIA KLV-40ZX1M KDL-32L5000	 KDL-37L5000 KDL-40S5100 KDL-46S5100 KDL-46V5100 KDL-46VE5 KDL-40W5100 KDL-40XBR7 KDL-46XBR8 KDL-32XBR9 KDL-40XBR9 KDL-46XBR9 KDL-40Z5100 KDL-46Z5100 Mount World 1262 Black Swivel Tilt Wall Mount for Sony HDTV BRAVIA KLV-40ZX1M KDL-32L5000 KDL-37L5000 KDL-40S5100 KDL-46S5100 KDL-46V5100 KDL-46VE5 KDL-40W5100 KDL-40XBR7 KDL-46XBR8 KDL-32XBR9 KDL-40XBR9 KDL-46XBR9 KDL-40Z5100 KDL-46Z5100
Sale Price: $49.99

Enhance your viewing experience with this TV wall mount.Fully articulating arm for displays ranging from 32" to 52" LCD and LED. Television mount constructed of durable heavy gauge steel.